Tag Archives: FIDO U2F security

Two-factor authentication hackable?

13 May 2018

Report “Two-factor authentication hackable” (1) published by Doug Olenick’ on May 10, 2018 at SC Media US is really frightening.

Two-factor authentication (TFA) is a great means to secure users of web services against phishing attacks. I’m aware that TFA with SMS or authenticator apps is not 100% secure because the login is not bound to the service, which means that TFA is prone to Man-in-the-Middle attacks. But the title of the report suggests that TFA is no longer secure at all.

A closer look at the report shows that Doug Olenick describes a Man-in-the-Middle attack initiated by a fake URL in an e-mail. The URL points to a web services which acts as a proxy for LinkedIn in this case. The proxy collects the users account details and the session cookie. Since the session cookie contains all details required to login to LinkedIn the attacker can hijack the users account without being requested of the password and the second factor.

For details about the attack see Kuba Gretzky’s post “Evilginx – Advanced Phishing with Two-factor Authentication Bypass” (2).

What can we learn from these reports?

TFA is vulnerable against phishing and Man-in-the-Middle attacks. User awareness and anti-phishing training become not obsolete once TFA with authenticator app or SMS is rolled out in an organization.

Although TFA is vulnerable this should not stop you from implementing TFA.

FIDO U2F Key (6)

FIDO U2F Key (6)

If you want to get it right the first time implement TFA with hardware keys, e.g. FIDO U2F keys. With hardware keys the user login is bound to the original service, which means that only the real site can authenticate with the service. For details see the FIDO alliance (3) homepage or the Yubico (4) homepage. For a great user story see report “Google Eliminates Account Takeover with the YubiKey” (5).

Have a great week.


  1. Olenick D. Two-factor authentication hackable [Internet]. SC Media US. 2018 [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from: https://www.scmagazine.com/network-security/two-factor-authentication-hackable/article/765135/

  2. Gretzky K. Evilginx – Advanced Phishing with Two-factor Authentication Bypass [Internet]. BREAKDEV. 2017 [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from: http://breakdev.org/evilginx-advanced-phishing-with-two-factor-authentication-bypass

  3. FIDO Alliance. https://fidoalliance.org/ [Internet]. FIDO Alliance. [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from: https://fidoalliance.org/

  4. U2F – FIDO Universal 2nd Factor Authentication [Internet]. Yubico. [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from: https://www.yubico.com/solutions/fido-u2f/

  5. Yubico.com. Google Eliminates Account Takeover with the YubiKey [Internet]. Yubico. [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from: https://www.yubico.com/about/reference-customers/google/

  6. Picture Credits: Amazon.de. [cited 2018 May 13]. Available from: https://www.amazon.de/Yubico-Y-123-FIDO-U2F-Security/dp/B00NLKA0D8

 

Advertisements

Review: Poor password practices put 60% of UK citizens at risk

4 December 2014

Poor password practices put 60% of UK citizens at risk.

Warwick Ahsford’s report is really alarming.  ‘More than six in 10 UK consumers put their data at risk by using a single password across multiple online accounts, a study has shown.’

But the worst is yet to come. They are using also weak passwords: ‘Trustwave analysed more than 625,000 password hashes and found 54% were cracked in just a couple of minutes and 92% in 31 days.’

Passwords are definitely inappropriate for authentication in the age of cyber crime. The news of the past weeks show that major players on the IT market like Twitter, Microsoft or Google developed technologies to address this problem.

FIDO U2F Security Key

FIDO U2F Security Key

The FIDO U2F standard (FIDO = Fast Identity Online Alliance, U2F = Universal second Factor) appears to be a quantum leap towards secure authentication in the world-wide web. Google has already integrated this standard in the Chrome browser. The second factor is established by a security key attached to a USB port.

Unfortunately it comes to fruition only after login into your computer, phone or tablet Computer, and only for Chrome.

And that’s in my opinion the crux of the matter. In a perfect world, I would like to login to my computer with a PIN or fingerprint and the FIDO U2F security key attached to the device.

A central, world-wide available and trusted identification authority verifies my identity and creates my identity token, which is valid for the duration of my session.

All services like Google, Home Depot, Amazon, the city council or the tax office rely on this identity token. For reasons of security the identity must be checked again before critical transactions are carried out.

Sounds fantastic, doesn’t it?

Look forward to a world without passwords!